Am I expecting too much of a nursing home?
I am the primary caregiver for my mom, who is 85 and has dementia. I have done everything I can to support her at home so she could stay there as long as possible. This past June she had to go to the hospital, then needed rehab. I found a facility close to myself and my other siblings and decided that the best long term solution for her would be for her to transfer to the nursing home side of the rehab because she needs more care than we can realistically provide at this point. It was a difficult decision, and it isn't finalized yet (legal paperwork battles with nursing home). I spent the summer looking at every possible option...other nursing homes, assisted living facilities, 24 hr home care. I have a brother and sister who really wanted her to go home, and thought she didn't need 24 hr care. But they let me make the decision, and I felt she wasn't safe without 24 hr care. We can get her in AL for a year or two then she moves to Medicaid and she would have to go back to a nursing home b/c she surpasses the Medicaid threshold for the amount of income she has coming in. I don't think we can sustain home care financially either long term, and Medicaid does not cover home care. Right now my mom is on respite at the nursing home and I told them it's a transition period to see if both she and my siblings can buy in to the idea of her staying there. Now they ask to change her room from a rehab to a long term bed. My concern is that my mom is verbal and still social and understands quite a bit, and her roommate is nonverbal, not interactive. So my mom will get no stimulation. My bigger concern than that, however, is that her roommate screams and I know this will keep my mom awake and agitate her. The social worker said I was entitled to a hearing to express my concerns and when it happened, the director basically said, "I hear your concerns, we have to move her." There are many empty beds in the rehab section so I don't see an emergency. I explained about the buy in, said this wouldn't serve us well, and asked if we could put this off until she is off of respite (which we are paying for privately to the tune of $10,000). They moved her anyway and she is not happy. This is the closest nursing home to us and visits are very important to my mom but it makes me wonder if we should just give her a couple good years in assisted living or at home. Am I expecting too much in wanting them to listen to a family member and their concerns? I am just not sure what to do.
12 Answers
Popular Questions
- My mom has Alzheimer's and she is in a nursing home. I get physically ill at the thought of going to see her and I have to force myself to go. Does anyone else have this problem?
- Nursing home neglect! My mothers is in ICU, now what?
- Do you feel that putting someone in a nursing home is just giving them a place to die in?
Related Questions
- My Dad (79) needs a temporary nursing home for rehab. Any ideas?
- My brother is in a New Hampshire County hospital. It's a whole day trip to see him for one hour. How can I get him transferred closer?
- What can I do when a Long Term Care facility refuses to let me visit?
- My sister is in rest home, her husband used her SS for him and did not pay rest home. My Mom wants us to pay the rest home. What do we do?
Spend the night with Mom.
You will hear staff with loud voices.
Doors banging.
Porters bringing heaven knows what ever night at 4 am (Cheerfully)
Room mates getting changed (Push out that bed table, crank up the bed etc)
People being taken out to the ER.
The worst room is the one by the nurses station (Where we can keep a good eye on her)
Weeping and wailing relatives when some one dies.
I can go one and on.
Some of it is unavoidable but some of it is just stupidity.
A nursing home or hospital is not a pretty place to spend the night.
Then around 5am the kitchen springs into action and the smell of bacon cooking wafts in the windows and breakfast is not for another three hours!!!!!!! ----- boy could I use a cup of tea right NOW but there is only luke warm water on the night stand and just out of reach. nurse "neat and tidy" pushed it just too far away when she came to do the vitals at 6am or even earlier if she wanted to make sure she left bang on 7 when the shift changed. She has to get home fast because hubby went to work at 6 and her eldest is only 8.
Or maybe last night it was the Aide they just hired. She is only 58 but 100 lbs over weight and worst of all has been compensating for her early dementia for over five years now. She shouts because she thinks every one of the patients is stone deaf and anyway she can't hear too well herself. She barely squaked by getting her CNA last year. She was a RN in her country of origin but no hope of passing the exams here and her English is barely passable. She calls everyone "Darlik" but she actually has a heart of gold----------well whats left off it after the revolution..
Sorry to make this sound of no consequence Rosie but like ladee M been there seen all that. I really do see your dilema and kudos to you for making every effort to make Mom's last years as tolerable as possible. the only place you could have complete control is at home but can you afford help. (At least $10 an hour) so you can continue to fulfil all your other responsibilities and not burn out as have so many other have after a few months. Other family members have a nasty habit of disappearing even if they do offer to help at the begining. most have an aversion to dirty diapers or more pressing engagements. It's a hard life and you just have to do the best you can and make something work. Blessings
Here is something else to consider: What if you were to find another facility, private pay, who did not accept people with night disturbances. And after a year or two your mother developed night disturbances herself? She has dementia and it is really hard to predict exactly what symptoms she will develop or how well she will respond to treatment.
Sigh. Complicated doesn't begin to cover the situation!
I think the staff where my mother is do their best to treat the person who is making the disturbance with dignity and compassion. They usually bring my mother out near the nursing station and give her something to do, like folding towels, until her is tired enough and calm enough to return to bed. They never make it seem like a punishment, but they do try to minimize the length of time she continues to disturb others.
I guess the ideal roommates for the night-screamers would be deaf people. But what about the people who shout loud enough to be heard down the hall?
You are right in your original statement. Nursing Homes are very complicated living situations. The needs of one and the needs of many are being constantly balanced. And they are generally being balanced without regard to who is paying what, as far as I can see.
Moving a person with dementia from one environment to another is very hard on them and requires another long adjustment period with each move. If you don't think this is the right place for your mother, move her soon rather than letting her get adjusted there.
Medicaid bases the in-home care on an evaluation of need. My husband qualified for 28 hours a week. I chose to use that for 4 8-hour days. I kept him home with me for the 10 years he had dementia. My mother qualified for a few hours a day of in-home care, but it became clear that she needed more than could be provided in a home environment. She is thriving in the nursing home! (Caring for a parent or for a spouse are two VERY different situations, in my opinion.)
You have to decide what is the best place (of all the less-than-perfect choices) for mother, and then advocate to make the best of it. I don't suppose you are going to find perfection.
Rehab (at least at the nursing home mom was at when she broke her hip) entails three sessions a week EACH from an occupational, physical and speech therapist. With room and rehab charges covered 100% by Medicare. If mom is taking up a bed and not getting rehab, they feel they can better optimize bed use if they move her and get someone in there that IS.
If my mom were bunking with someone who kept her awake at night or disturbed her and I were paying $10K a month? She'd be moved in a week -- either to a new room or a new nursing home.
She has has the gold make the rules. Private pay earns just about anything you want. Somewhere.
Are there any private rooms available? They would cost more, of course, and she would need Medicaid sooner, then she would have to move. But it might buy her a better experience for the immediate term.
(Medicaid actually does cover in-home care, by the way, but not at a 24-hour-per-day level.)