Follow
Share

Our mom is 90 and lives alone. She has 4 daughters, the oldest is barely involved. Three of us are caring for mom but the oldest sister has very little to do with mom and does nothing for her care. But she wants us to keep her updated on everything which I wouldn't even mind but each update has her making recommendations and suggesting things to do. She has no idea what is going on or what state our mom is in on any given week. So I end up writing lengthy replies to address all her questions or tell her it's already being done. How do we deal with this? Btw this sister has an explosive personality and often leaves cussing and storming out from holiday events and other major events. I believe she has some kind of unaddressed mental health or personality disorder. I am exhausted from caring for mom, working part time (this same sister was off for a year during the pandemic while all 3 of us were still working and she did nothing to help. She has no children), trying to see my 6 grandkids and volunteering with my church and community and she is making my life even more overwhelming. What is the proper way to deal with this...I don't want to be cruel especially for my mom's sake who has always protected her and takes up for her.... also annoying.
Thank you for your insights from outside:)
Paula

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Continue making her aware in the way you say you don't mind, give her updates then disengage completely, you don't need to respond to her replies or even read them. 🤫
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
Firstof5 Oct 2021
Yes, exactly.
(2)
Report
I would give a very vague positive update.

Nothing new to report this week. Love ya

She doesn't need a play by play commentary on what's going on and if she does, well, I might give her too much information.

Mom has had 3 BMs today, approximately 10grams, 40 grams and 25 grams. So happy she made it to the commode because they were very stinky. Peed 15 times, used 6 depends that weighed a total of 35 oz each. Picked her nose, wiped her own butt. Burped after drinking water, dribbled OJ on her PJ's, hugged sissie and myself, scratched the cat and so on.

Honestly, unless someone is part of the care team they just need to be notified of a crisis or hospitalization. The day to day doesn't need to be shared.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
Beatty Oct 2021
💩🤣🤣🤣
(5)
Report
I had the same problem with my sisters.
The way I dealt with all the questions and suggestions was

"The doctors/nurses say mom is doing as well as expected."

The suggestions were dealt with
" I'll pass that on to the doctors/nurses".
That was it. No long involved explanations.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
Beatty Oct 2021
Love it.

When I finally learnt this trick - whoa! What a different. I use 'doing well' or similar as a bland *Headline* 😊 No need to drill down into the story details. It takes practice (especially for a talker like me) but SO worth it.

It removes you from the drama the asker is stirring up.
(2)
Report
You're probably right that your sister has some undiagnosed issue. It's probably better for everyone that she not be doing caregiving. Be thankful you don't have to deal with her poor behavior on a regular basis.

She might be trying to be helpful when giving advice on how to deal with things. I'd take it as her way to contribute. She might have some good advice even though you don't have time to respond to everything.

You could just give her a quick, positive, vague response. Thanks for your input. Lots of great ideas there. Have a good day!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

I have a similar sibling and I think above advice is all good. Short, sweet and to the point emails. She wants more details? She can come visit Mom or call her! (I tell my sibling to call our father every time she's "suddenly interested" in what's going on with him)
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

I have been there in a different way with one of my brothers. He wasn't demanding but would give input from a hands off aspect, didn't acknowledge the hours, time and money my husband and I spent there, and would also deny that my mother was as bad as I reported. I was constantly trying to fill him in via email, and he never validated anything I reported and often made cold and judgmental replies or none at all. I realized that I was unconsciously feeling intimidated to gain his approval. I never did.
What I'm saying is stop writing emails. Your sister has her own issues and is obviously used to getting her way through bullying tactics. You will never change her perspective but you do have a couple of options, pick from the menu below.
1 .Let your other siblings write the updates
2. Tell you sister she needs to start helping out or there will be no more updates.
3. Never give detailed emails. Keep it short and vague. Mom's doing great. Mom saw the doctor and he increased her meds. Mom mentioned she misses you.
4. Don't ever respond to a nasty email from her.
5. Ask her for specific help. "Can you please visit Mom next Thursday?" I have appointments and errands and she shouldn't be alone". "Can you start contributing to taking Mom to her appointments"? Be direct, Don't be intimidated or bullied. Leave emotions out of every conversation.
6. Give up the idea of ever pleasing her, and stop trying to.
7. In the final analysis, you know that you are going the distance with and for your Mom, and that will be a comfort to you all the days of your life. Focus on that, and eliminate the emotional charge of dealing so often with your sister and her mental issues.
I truly wish you peace on your journey of care taking.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Hi Paula,

That’s very frustrating. I suspect she cares, wants to be involved, but knows herself enough to know that she can’t handle any of the “caring for” herself.

Right now I’m looking after my father (in hospital after having suffered a stroke) and my mother who is pretty helpless. My brother lives halfway across the world, so is of little help but likes to stay informed.

I email weekly updates on Dad’s current progress and sometimes include photos. He usually ends up emailing me info that I already know (which I in turn ignore) and I rarely respond to his messages. I let him know in my emails how busy I am, and apologize in advance if I can’t respond to any questions (you might throw in here how if she really needs to know something, you’re sure Mom would love a phone call from her).

I don’t know if it’s just my personality, but I apologize and apologize, and ignore and ignore and go on my merry way. Like you I am BUSY (I also have a MIL with dementia at home as well as 2 kids under 8) so I can’t be everybody’s everything without a lot of sacrifice. I just keep saying, “I’m sorry if I don’t get back to you right away! Life is so crazy busy right now, but I’m doing my best!!!” That usually shuts people up.

Deep breath, and don’t waste your breath getting into it with her. It’s honestly not worth the headache.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Give her quick, factual updates and don’t reply to her questioning or suggestions. You don’t owe her more than that and shouldn’t subject yourself to being bullied
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Sure, she may have issues and she wants to help, but can’t get past them. But that’s her deal, not yours, right? You’re running yourself ragged trying to juggle this. Your updates should adhere to what works for you. Your time has value. Why not tell her that your family activities are picking up again, and it’s easier for you to touch base with her X (1 ?) times a week in the format of your choosing. Maybe a 2-5 minute phone call each week at a time you’re up for it? Schedule phone calls so that they’re before something you need to do, so you can get off the call. As others have suggested, this doesn’t need to be a time consuming back and forth. Condense your written updates so that there’s less opportunity for armchair quarterbacking. You don’t have to answer every phone call from her right away, either. Or share doing the updates among all 3 sisters. If that fails, invite her over for something that’s time limited—maybe she could visit and drop off lunch or a treat for mom, & invite her to stay if she wants to. Then she gets limited eyes on time. My brother loves my mom, but he can only take very small doses of her, so he does the taxes- a huge load off me. So he’s helpful, but not present. Maybe there’s something like that she could help with? It could take some of the load off of you & your sisters too.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Send her a short report then do not respond to her questions/suggestions. When asked why you do not respond…tell her you are so busy helping take care of mom that you have little time left over.. Seriously you do not owe her anything. She can show up, help, chat with mom and learn how mom is. Set some boundaries between the two of you…perhaps a counselor could help you..Mine helped me.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

See All Answers
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter