Follow
Share
Find Care & Housing
Short answer - no. She was fired for cause.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Taarna
Report

Whoever paid her bills.
People are fired all the time and this doesn't necessarily mean you are responsible for unemployment.
Perhaps it depends on how you paid her ... with a check? did you take out taxes? Are you reporting her income? If you are giving her a check as an independent contractor, then NO. She is on her own.

Consult an attorney if this is a potentially huge headache / financial burden.
Abandonment is serious.

Gena / Touch Matters
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to TouchMatters
Report

If you go to the police and make a report of negligence and abandonment; then you can use the report and any other evidence to employment office. You just need proof that she wasn't there and your loved one was under the aide's care/protection.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Sloyce3443
Report
MargaretMcKen 12 hours ago
"If you go to the police and make a report of negligence and abandonment" I'd surprised if you even get past the front desk, let alone a report. That's not a police matter.
(1)
Report
In my past experience working in HR and Payroll, if the employee actually files an unemployment claim, the Department of Workforce services, or whatever it is called where you live, will contact the employer, (you or your sister) to verify the individual was terminated and why.
Sometimes, if there is a dispute, or the person was fired for cause, there will be a telephone hearing.

Of course, this is all assuming your sister, the employer, had unemployment insurance, which is required of all employers. The employer does not pay out of pocket for unemployment claims. The state will pay benefits to the individual.
But, you still have the right to dispute their claim for benefits if they were rightfully terminated for cause.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to CaringWifeAZ
Report

from the Federal website:
https://www.uschamber.com/co/run/human-resources/can-fired-employees-collect-unemployment
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to MACinCT
Report

Whether you are responsible for paying unemployment benefits after firing an in home caregiver for abandonment and tardiness depends on the specific circumstances and the laws in your state. Here are some general guidelines:

Misconduct and unemployment eligibility: In many states, an employee who is fired for misconduct may be disqualified from receiving unemployment benefits. Misconduct typically includes actions like abandonment of duty or chronic tardiness, especially if the employer has provided warnings or a clear policy regarding attendance.

Burden of Proof: As an employer, you would likely need to prove that the caregiver’s actions were a serious violation of workplace policies, they were aware of these policies and the consequences for not adhering to them, and you gave warnings or chances for improvement before termination.

Unemployment eligibility rules vary by state. In some states, repeated tardiness or a single incident of abandonment may be sufficient grounds for denying benefits, while in others, the threshold for “misconduct” might be higher.

If you operate in an at will employment state, you can terminate an employee for any lawful reason, but the termination reason still affects unemployment claims. If the state determines the cause doesn’t rise to the level of misconduct, the caregiver could still qualify for benefits.

Even if the caregiver qualifies for unemployment, it typically doesn’t mean you pay directly. Employers pay into the state’s unemployment insurance fund, and claims might increase your future unemployment insurance tax rate.

What you can do: Review your state’s unemployment laws. Document all issues with tardiness and abandonment, including warnings and policies. Consult with an attorney to assess whether the termination aligns with “misconduct” under your state’s laws.

Ultimately, understanding your state’s specific unemployment laws and thoroughly documenting performance issues can help protect your interests as an employer.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to HaveYourBack
Report

Aquwhi: Most likely you do not have to offer her unemployment pay if there was no contract in writing and she was a private hire whose services you paid for in cash.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Llamalover47
Report

Maybe. If you hired her directly as a W4 employee and withheld social security and medicare from her paychecks, you may be responsible for federal unemployment tax (FUTA). It will depend on how much she was paid and how long she worked. You may also have requirements at the state level that depend on where you live. You don't pay unemployment yourself - that's on the state - but you may need to pay unemployment tax.
If you hired her "off-books" and didn't pay or collect taxes, you are likely both violating tax and employment law, so it isn't in anyone's interest to pursue unemployment. If you hired thru an agency, it's not your problem.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to elcee499
Report

"Fired for cause" might allow you to not have to pay unemployment, but may require supporting documentation of the "causes."
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to RedVanAnnie
Report

There may be a rule in your state that requires the employer to pay something if the employee is laid off. My husband was fired once, and when he applied for unemployment, his employer said he was fired for cause and therefore didn’t qualify. Why would they contest if they didn’t have to pay? If you fired that person for cause, you may not have to pay. My husband had to go before an Administrative Law Judge for a hearing. So I would just wait for the state to contact you, fill out the form saying your employee was fired for cause and see what happens.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Kartyjb
Report

You have to take out unemployment for a person to be able to collect it. In my state they have to work 13 weeks consecutively to apply. Being fired means waiting longer to collect.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

Unemployment is a government program and the government (through your taxes) pays for an employee. Whether they pay or do not pay is complicated. And not up to you. You will only answer questions if asked. So not to worry. None of this is now in your hands. You have fired the tardy worker and you now get on with your own life.

Do know that unemployment rules are specific to both state and federal rules at times, and complicated. Not something you have to think of but if you have an interest in researching you can do so via the internet.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

If she was privately hired and you were paying her in cash and there's no written contract or proof of employment, then no.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
KPWCSC 13 hours ago
But if the lady applies for unemployment, there will be an inquiry and it may lead to penalties.
(0)
Report
If this person was working with an agency, she would apply through the state. The state would determine if she qualifies or not and the state would pay her accordingly to what she made the entire year and break it up into quarters.

You wouldn't have to pay unemployment out of pocket as long as you were paying the proper taxes for her and issued her a 1099 form so she could go file with the state..

Now, if she was a private aide you hired, she would still have to file a claim with the city and state. Just make sure you give her the proper documentation 1099 form to do so. Working privately or under the table so to speak, I think if she pleads a big enough case, she can get something as long as she has the proper paperwork. I'm not sure how this will work out for her if she doesn't.

She can try to file a file a lawsuit, but what what she have to go on without any documentation?
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Scampie1
Report
elcee499 15 hours ago
Form 1099 applies to an independent contractor who runs their own business and pays their own taxes. This is common, but per the IRS it doesn't usually include household workers. You would not be responsible for paying unemployment on an independent contractor. If you hire the employee and direct their work, they may be classified as a W4 employee. In that case, you withhold social security and medicare from their paycheck, and must also contribute an equal amount.
(2)
Report
Hi! I suggest that you wait and see if the person you have fired actually does anything other than talk and threaten. If it goes further, please could you use more ‘normal’ language? Sometimes people use what they think are formal or legal terms, which in fact really obscure what is going on, and I suspect that you have fallen into that trap.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter