Follow
Share

She’s wheelchair bound; she can’t stand up alone due to her extreme fear of falling, won’t even cooperate with a physical therapist. BUT when she desperately wants to get out of there, will try to stand up out of her chair only to fall down. At night she flails around in bed trying to get out of it..and then what? fall to the ground! She has a long-term catheter because she’s unable to pee without it.
She’s currently in a nice clean 6-bed facility. They take good care of her, but she desperately wants to come home. When I visit (daily), she’s fixated on going home with me and demands I don’t dare leave without her, when I must eventually. It’s horrible! I’m alone, am 85, and I can’t possibly give her the help she needs at home. Now again I ask, is in-home care for her a real possibility? I personally don’t see how it could be, but asking anyway.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I'm so sorry you are both going through this.

It sounds like she is Sundowning. This is a feature of dementia that usually starts to happen in the afternoons. The "home" they wish to go to is actually their childhood home since that's what is in their long-term memory.

At-home care is possible but is it beneficial? The caregiving arrangement has to work for both the care receiver and the giver. In home care for her level of need will be very, very expensive. Eventually 24/7 in-home care will exceed the cost of a facility.

If she is a fall risk at night, how do you expect to get any sleep? Even if she has devices in place that prevent her from successfully getting out of bed, could she still scream for you?

Others will post their personal experiences. I wish you much wisdom and peace in your heart as you come to conclusions.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

So sorry, but I don't think in home care would work. Probably no cheaper than where she is. And you will have strangers in your home and you needing to manage them. Agencies are not always the best thing.

If you are going staying into the late afternoon, maybe leave earlier. They always want to go home but its not always the last one she lived in. Could be a childhood home. They take good care of her, then keep her there. I knew a man who had to finally place his wife. He went everyday and had lunch with her and stayed till dinner time.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

No, it’s not a good idea. The place where she is now can take care of her better than home caregivers. Plus you need to maintain your own health, mental and otherwise. That’s hardly possible at home with someone with such severe issues in residence.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

No, as you know, it simply isn't a realistic option.

I don't know how bad her dementia is, but if she's actually talking about going home to YOUR home, this is really just a case of not being able to accept the inevitable changes that life brings to us all whether we like it or not. There's no reasoning that will fix the situation, just acceptance or a life of misery.. Ultimately, our bodies fail us and they dictate where we life

It's something we all dread, and unless we're "fortunate" enough to live a fairly independent life then die in our sleep, it's all going to come to us one day eventually.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Only you really know the answer to your question as you know your physical and mental limits. You have to do not only what is best for your wife but also for yourself. It's hard, I know. I took care of my husband who had vascular dementia at home until he died in 2020. He was completely bedridden the last 22 months of his life, and under hospice care, so that made it a bit easier as I didn't have to worry about him falling all the time. The hospice nurse came once a week to start, and aides came to bathe him twice a week, and I had to hire an aide to come put him on the bedside commode to poop, as he too had a permanent catheter, so that was helpful, but still left 99% of his care on me.
Also one of the ladies in my caregiver support group cared for her husband who had Parkinson's and Lewy Body dementia in their home until he passed last year. She did it on her own until hospice was needed towards the end, but he too became completely bedridden, so she didn't have to worry about him falling.
So unless you perhaps have a hospital bed that she couldn't get out of and hire some in-home help, you may want to leave well enough alone.
Lewy Body dementia is pretty aggressive, and the life expectancy isn't typically very long,(5-7 years)so it may be time to bring hospice on board even if she stays where she's at.
I wish you the very best as I know how hard this all is.
May God bless you and keep you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I think you know the answer yourself. It is too hard and you should not feel guilty.
My husband has Parkinson’s but no dementia and is independent, he does not need help with meds, has mobility issues, walks on his own but uses walker as well.
Your wife would benefit from PT, as it is helpful not just for mobility but pivoting, but as I know nothing about dealing with dementia it is hard to say, but, maybe worth trying another PT.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Anything is possible, but is it practical and sustainable?

You already know the answer. As hard as it is, she's probably better off where she can be cared for and not by you. You are wonderful to go see her everyday. But let the CG's do their jobs.

I'm so sorry for what you are going through,
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

Blame it on the doctor. Say that you're sorry and wish she could be home with you but the doctor says it would not be safe.

Have a plan for how to change the subject after you tell her this same answer to going home every day. Be ready to talk about something else right away.

Maybe she needs some additional anti-anxiety pills?
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Only you know whether you can afford 24/7 round the clock at home care for your wife, and whether you yourself can bear the burden of such a thing. I don't even know that one caregiver would be enough to manage her needs; you might need two, and then an overnight caregiver, upping the costs significantly. If you can't afford such costs, then the answer is a flat out no, and that's that. If you can afford the astronomical costs, then you have to ask yourself if YOU can bear the burden of having your wife around the house 24/7 being uncooperative and suffering from Lewy Body Dementia and PD? There is no shame in saying No, I cannot bear such a thing. Very few of us would be able to, in reality.

That said, I am so sorry you are faced with such a situation. That illness of this magnitude has put your wife AND you into such a state where you're both miserable and suffering daily. Where she is insisting on 'going home' and you're faced with dealing with her demands all the time. That is very wearing on a person, I know. My mother lived in a wonderful Memory Care ALF for nearly 3 years with advanced dementia and I had to deal with her wanting to 'go home' and all sorts of other ugliness. It wears a person out, is what it does. It lingers on one's mind and strips the joy out of life. It creates guilt and a sense of a dark cloud hanging over everything, and like we don't deserve to laugh or feel good b/c our loved one is suffering so. Is that how you are feeling too? If so, I get it. I'm not sure there's any 'answer' to such a situation, either, and if there is, I wasn't able to find it myself for the duration of my mother's stay in Memory Care. The only relief came when God called her home this past February and took her out of her misery and back to wholeness once again, to be honest with you. Nobody wins when disease of this caliber is present; we all suffer.

Sending you a hug and a prayer for peace with such a sad and debilitating situation.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

If she is being taken care of and as hard as it is you need to leave her there...some of her anxiety is the dementia...in home health can help but for her safety she is where she needs to be...it's so very difficult I know my dad used to ask me when he was going home and it broke my heart everytime I had to tell him he must stay but I knew it was the only thing I could do...I am now faced with the same dilemma...my mom has dementia and macular degeneration and her eyesight has gotten much worse...she still lives at home and for the most part does very well however the dementia has progressed and I am faced with the decision of keeping her home and hiring extra help or place her in a facility and I hate that thought...as caregivers we also have to think of our own well-being and that's harder...I drive 3 hours one way to care for my mom every week...we love them so hang in there and try to change the subject and give lots of reassurance...
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

Ssounds like AL or SNF is necessary for your wife, but please check with her doctors. Similar to my brother's PD situation what happened this past summer. He lacked judgement, so he fell in his room and hit his head, thankfully only suffered a contusion, sent him to SNF for rehab then discharged in just two weeks, then sent back to AL.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My husband had LBD and Parkinson’s… when he asked why he wasn’t at home … I told him truth … I couldn’t take proper care of him at home… he would run out during night saying he was meeting friends … had hallucinations delusions… I had 24 hr care but it was truly crazy … until I found really nice private care home …there he was safe and well cared for … I visited everyday and took him on outings .. haircuts restaurants … parks … ice cream .. the 2nd year he was stuck in wheelchair and couldn’t transfer …
we had lunch /dinner everyday .. lots his favourite foods … takeouts etc …
i think he understood He needed lots care was always happy see me and I hope he forgave me … but the guilt was always there …
he was safe and well cared for and I was with him everyday… we were able to be husband and wife with dignity till end .
Helpful Answer (13)
Report

So sorry you are going through this. The journey many of us -- including you -- are on, is not a fun one.

No one person on their own can safely provide the level of 24/7 care your loved one (LO) likely needs now. Safety and proper care for you have to come first, even over the pleadings of the LO to "go home."

In know from personal experience -- dealing with my mom in a similar situation -- this is so, very hard. It breaks our hearts to hear the "take me home pleadings" from a LO, but that reality often is not possible.

I am not a physician, not a nurse, not a physical therapist, not a psychologist, not a dentist, not an optometrist, not a social worker, not a podiatrist, not a dietician, not medical transport, not a 24/7 on-call aide; all of which my mom's highly rated nursing home has and she needs all of those services. Trying to be or take on all of these positions -- so proper and safe care is proved to your LO -- as one person 24/7 is not doable. It is not feasible.

Accepting what your LO wants is not feasible is the hardest part. Trying to explain it to them is unrealistic too because with dementia their ability to understand and reason -- much less remember -- makes such explanations impossible. Best as others have said, to come up with a brief simple response and to get comfortable say the same thing every time the topic comes up: "When the doctor says it is safe, we can talk about it then." And then change the subject; distract and redirect to an entirely different topic if you can.

Now if resources are not an issue, it could be a different matter. We have another family member -- she is 96, has dementia and host of other issues, including not able to walk, not continent -- who has remained at home. Her husband left her with a boat load of money. So her adult kids opted for spending it all on 24/7 care so she could remain home. The cost for 3 full time aides -- they split shifts for the week -- is $10K a week and that does not include the weekly visiting nurse or other services. At $40K per month plus the other expenses, it will be about about 1/2 a million for the year. Obviously, most people do not have this level of resources for quality 24/7 care at home......
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

My heart goes out to you both. You’re clearly a dedicated, loving husband. Please, this lovely small six bed facility is equipped and trained care for her specific needs. Bringing her home will inevitably lead to even more heartbreak.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

It sounds like the 6 bed facility is nice.

Read up on reflective conversation. Start using those strategies.
Example....wife "I want to go home." you "I'm sure you do. The doctor says you need to stay longer. Tomorrow there are some good movies on TV. Do you want us to watch ____ or ___.


Whenever she starts talking about going home you need to immediately change the subject in conversation. That is called reflective conversation or redirecting.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Safety must always be primary consideration. It does not sound like a " safe" decision for you as an 85 yo, alone , to even consider taking your beloved home.
Be at peace with yourself and your present care arrangements in the facility for her; I know this grieves her and you, but you really are doing the safe thing for you both.

It is common for patients in facility care to guilt trip and beat up on lived ones visiting about wanting to go home. Redirect the conversation to something else. If she continues unrelentingly, gently say you love her and that you have to be going and will see her again soon. Do not stay for long visits or even short visits that are not healthy for either of you , and , listening to her go on and on about an unrealistic request is unhealthy for you both. Speak with your community support such as your pastor or a local chaplain to get self support as you make this long arduous and grief provoking journey with your wife. So sorry ....
Peace
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Lovemydoggies Oct 2022
You are so right. Listening to someone go on and on and on about doing anything is encouraging the behavior. As long as they have a willing audience, they will perform.
(1)
Report
I know this is terribly hard but do not bring her home. She is safe where she is and at 85 caring for her will be extremely difficult. What happens if you bring her home and then you have a health situation of your own? What happens to her then? Leave her where she is safe and you have piece of mind.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Absolutely not. She will not be safe at home. Remain her husband and let the professionals be her caretakers.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

The only way to bring her home is if like another poster said, you have a lot of money for her care. My mom wanted to stay home but when we looked into it and a live in is about 22k a month. Not including meals and the home expenses themselves. More with someone who needs more care. So if you don’t have the financial resources your ONLY option is to keep her at her facility. This brings me to planning for your future for these situations. I’m 60 and I’ve started an investment fund for my care just in case. The expense is outrageous for a DECENT facility and I’m not counting on anyone to take care of me. Not my husband nor my son but myself with smart planning ahead.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Sharovd Nov 2022
Have you looked into long term care insurance for yourself. At age 60, it might still be affordable.
(0)
Report
You are a good husband and doing the best that you can which is pretty darn good. Be at peace with yourself knowing that.
How did you find a six bed facility?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

So painful to watch… but …

Can you physically lift your wife when she falls? Get her in and out of the shower? Up and down stairs? To and from appointments (and in bad weather)? Will she actually do PT at home? Will you become a recluse because she might fall when you leave to run errands (or have a life)? Can you manage little things… like twice the amount of laundry? Her catheter? Retrofitting the car for a wheelchair or buying a van? Calls to come home when you run errands? The “I need, I want” fetching? Bad nights sleep because she flails and falls and keeps you awake? And everything else?

Someone posted an incredible insight about why mom can’t come home when their visits were so much fun. She said “I want to be your daughter, not your unhappy, stressed out caregiver.”

Your wife’s begging guilts you into questioning yourself when you know her care is beyond your capability. And since you love her, her pain and false belief that you can solve it must hurt on a visceral level.😔

Sending a 🤗.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Obviously, whether you CAN bring her home depends on how wealthy you are. I’m going to assume that you don’t have extraordinary strength and stamina for your age such that you can lift her from the floor and turn her in bed, so you would need 24/7 help. Can you afford that? Do you have the energy for the full time job of managing three shifts of caregivers, and to respond when they can’t manage her alone or she demands that you be the one to help? How about the lack of sleep when this happens at night? What happens when someone is sick or just doesn’t show up or quits suddenly and there’s no backup?

My MIL cared for my FIL with dementia by herself at home. He too constantly asked to “go home”. What then?

You are doing the best thing possible for her. Perfect just doesn’t happen at this stage.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

At home care is only possible with competent round the clock home health care aides. This might be more expensive than your finances can cover - and probably will not be covered by insurance. But, you can call local home health care companies to get their rates and see if this is possible.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

For the past 5 years my mother - now 95 - has lived with me. I'm 63 years old now and work very hard to stay strong and not let my health decline.

Caregiving will definitely threaten mental, spiritual, emotional and physical health.

If I were 85 years old there is no way.

My mother desperately wants to go home as well, which is her childhood home with her parents. I think that goes with dementia.

As it is, you can sleep at night without interruption, you can move about life as you see fit - you're not trapped at home. If your wife comes back home, those two things will end for you.

Even if you can afford night help, unless you live in a castle you're going to wake up and hear anything that goes on, thus interrupting your sleep.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

If you can afford 24/7 care and someone else to manage all the pitfalls of having employees, then I say; "go for it." Otherwise, you are risking your health, strength, and life. What happens to your wife wanting to "go home" when you are no longer home for her to go to?

I am speaking from experience. I was determined to take care of my husband who is 80 and has late-stage dementia. I tried everything from adult day care to full-time caregivers. My husband was "home," but never in his mind. His "home" was some fictional place where he was well and independent.

During the long five years of the ravages of LBD w/parkinsonian expressions and taking care of my husband's needs, my health deteriorated to the point where I am now on life-saving medications. I neglected going to my doctors because I was consumed with all the medical care of my husband. I just didn't have the strength to schedule appointments for me.

The good news is--my best friend and my son and his wife encouraged me to place my husband in a continuing care facility. July 5 after a 6-month long search. Within seven days after placing my husband I got Covid. I tested positive for ten days. Serendipitously, not being able to visit him allowed him time to adjust to the facilities routines, activities, and to develop friendships. He learned to accept the reality that I couldn't visit him often and that if he wanted to survive, he needed to depend on others rather than on me. In a way, he grew up emotionally.

Meanwhile, I am concentrating on staying alive so that I can manage his care, Doordash him surprises, shave him twice a week, and enjoy the little time we have together.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Is there a facility where you could live together there, but in separate places (you in Independent Care or Assisted and she in the Nursing section)? Call "A Place for Mom" or the "Care Advisor" here on this site..........over to the right here.

https://www.continuingcarecommunities.org/assisted-living/california/fontana.html
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Salsnh93: I am so sorry that your DW (Dear Wife) suffers from Parkinson's and Lewy Body Dementia. The thought process of the patient with dementia asking 'to go home' is a common dilemma seen pretty much across the board for most caregivers. That is, of course, not a reasonable request since the individual posing the question has a disease of the brain. You've already stated that you don't see how bringing her home could be feasible. If you indeed want to attempt this, be prepared to have to pay for a possible at two or three individuals. Best of luck during this most challenging time in your life.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

The answer is NO. You are 85 and unable to care for her. Unless you have 24 hour LIVE IN care ( which is extremely expensive) you are setting yourself and her up for failure and devastation. She needs to stay where she is. Bless you.💜
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

No answer; just a question. How, where did those of you who commented, find the wonderful placements you described?
I'm late to the role of care giver but I envision the end game some describe and it scares the hell out of me. She is 84, in dementia, Type II diabetes and neuropathy below both knees. I want the best care for my wife, lover and best friend of 59 yrs but I am truly her CONSTANT companion and feel my own health slipping. That can't be good for either of us.
I'm in Virginia midway between Fredericksburg and Richmond if you can point me to a really good assisted living (if that's the correct thing to be looking for) that you've found for your loved one.
Best.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
LovingHusband Feb 2023
Hi neighbor....I'm in Fredericksburg, caregiver for my bride of 42 years (she's 78). We received her diagnosis of DLB w/ Parkinsonism. We're still in our home and I provide her 24/7 care and will continue to so long as I'm physically able. But, I've begun research for the inevitable and found 'A Place for Mom' a good resource. Reach out and will compare notes. All the best!
(1)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter