Follow
Share
Read More
Dear Margaret, I’m still trying to clarify the specific information you’re seeking. It appears you may be asking for more details about the feedback my sister and I have received regarding our approach to Dad's situation, as well as whether this feedback has come from this forum or our own reflections. At the same time, it seems you want me to address whether I feel this forum's contributions have been 'unacceptable' and that y'all should just stop talking. 

Regarding the recent changes with Dad, they felt quite sudden, prompting a quick response from my sister and me. Given our history—our father physically and emotionally distanced himself almost 50 years ago—understanding the gradual nature of these changes is challenging. Our contact has been infrequent, and the most noticeable alert to a sudden condition was the significant delay in his response times to our calls. This is just one of many complexities I've left out of my posts, which makes it difficult to determine what details might be most useful for feedback.

I acknowledge that my initial response to AlvaDeer on my original post was defensive. I was in a heightened emotional state at the time. In retrospect, I recognize I should have addressed my reaction more openly. This forum is a space where we are all navigating deeply personal challenges, and it’s easy to forget that we are all striving to cope in our own ways.

I appreciate that everyone offers advice based on the information available, and I try to discern what is helpful and what may not resonate. With the exception of my initial response to Alva, I hope my responses have reflected this understanding.

In truth, I have found the insights shared in this forum to be quite helpful. My sister and I are actively seeking diverse perspectives to navigate our options, considering input from friends, professionals, and yes, even strangers online. While it remains a crisis, we have settled somewhat since the initial shock a few weeks ago.

I do not view the responses here as unacceptable objections, nor do I think the forum participants should "just shut up". I’ve expressed my gratitude for the feedback numerous times. I also now recognize the importance of being mindful with my words in this space.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Berls501
Report
AlvaDeer Oct 29, 2024
Oh, Berls, no problem here from me (ALVADEER). I am often blunt and people often reply to me in kind, and I have utterly NO problem here with you. I am in fact fascinated with this whole thing, and you DID tell us in your first statement of some estrangement. Originally my own fear was that Sister was off in CO and you in TX and that you might just take a mentally unstable Dad who has kind of ALWAYS been a bit of a problem to Sister who wouldn't know what she was getting, and there you would be, saddled with him. I also couldn't tell if he was "competent" or "incompetent" and as it turns out he is BOTH which is further complicating.
Trust me I understand the confusion here for all involved and only WISH I had some answer and I am afraid that I am where I was on DAY ONE which is that there isn't always, as Dr Laura says "an answer; not everything can be fixed".

To me, I think Dad may need to be a ward of the state. May he actually die in his hovel of a trailer? Yes, he MAY. But it is how he lived, what he chose, and to take him into a home he doesn't want to be, where sis won't be seen as a daughter, but as a jailer and caregiver, I don't think it will work for him or for her or for you. He will hate you all as the decision makers. It will be thankless, and while he may live another year or so, he would hate all involved if he is uncooperative.
That all, for me comes of having worked with my brother, the sweetest, kindest, cleanest, most organized, gentlest man in the world, and being POA and Trustee was STILL tough. But HE moved from HIS trailer (beautiful and full of his pottery and beloved monterey furniture) willingly, when he was diagnosed with Lewy's, gave me full POA/Trustee and begged me to protect his assets from his failing mind.
AND STILL IT WAS HARD.

I am all in and all with you, Berl.
No fears there. I support you and your sister in whatever you try. It may work, it may not, and such is life.
NOTHING to apologize here from my perspective. Say it like it IS. That's what I do, so I certainly had better be able to take it back, hee hee.
(2)
Report
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter