Follow
Share

My grandfather had severe dementia and was put in a Fl nursing home. He ended up falling and breaking his neck and dying from the injury during his stay. The hospital reported he had a broken back and multiple other fractures that happened prior to his death that the nursing home never told us about. Can we sue for wrongful death and what are the odds of winning?

Find Care & Housing
And what exactly do you feel that the Hospital did wrong that caused your Dad's injury? Sadly I think it will not come down to "odds of winning" but rather will be declined for pursuing by any attorney. Do not take my word for it, as consults in this regard will be free.

Sadly, in these times the max recovery for personal injury is often no more than 250,000.
While this may sound like a lot to you, it isn't a lot to an attorney, and they have to hire expert witnesses to the tune of more than this to beat big gun corporate attorneys hired on contingency by hospitals.

The other sad fact is the fact that, as Igloo says here, once you are over 60 years of age, any "value" legally and financially to your life is over. So recovery is not great.

The best lawsuits, the cherries picked by attorneys are those in which a young person with a great job making a lot of money is injured wrongly and clearly by a lot of evidence--and seriously enough that they need lifelong one-on-one care. Lots of recovery there. BUT lots of it needed as lifelong care will run to many millions of dollars.

There is nothing in all this to say that you cannot see an attorney, personal injury, to assure yourself that I am right. See two or three if that makes you feel better. You will understand so much more if they level honestly with you. Do internet research on personal injury lawsuits or medical malpractice also. Scroll past the 1000s of ads.

I am so very sorry for the loss of your granddad. I was a nurse lifelong and can assure you both as a nurse and as an 82 year old whose balance is shot, that Falls-R-Us for seniors.
Our balance is gone with aging and no matter how determined and strong we try to stay, we fall. And falls eventually result in injury. No matter the best you may try, we will fall, and a fall is often the beginning of the end, and was for my own Mom in her early 90s.
Again, I am so very sorry. I wish you the best of luck. I hope you'll update us.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

Last year, I inquired about lawsuits against a nursing home and having to pay Medicaid back. That was my question. I wasn't asking IF I had grounds to sue. Everyone but one person told me I didn't have a case or wouldn't win because of my mother's age and dementia. We did have have a case and we were quite pleased with the outcome. You need a good attorney that specializes in this area. Our attorney had even been a judge. Also, if you're told Medicaid will take all of it by people here, that's not true. They will seek reimbursement for medical expenses occurring AFTER the incident, however Medicaid pays very little to start with and our attorney said it's even negotiable. Medicaid paid so little on medical bills in our case we didn't ask for negotiations on that.

I'm sorry for the loss of your grandfather and I wish you the best of luck.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to PrimitiveGirl
Report

Your odds of any attorney accepting your suit are zero. First of all, and sadly, at end of life our lives are considered, under the law, not of much value. Compensation for injury and death is given for the number of lost years of earning capacity, and given for ongoing care needs over a long lifetime for injury done due to malpractice.

It is the "norm" for elders to fall. There were likely many falls that were unwitnessed and not even remembered, and there would be many injuries apparent to spine and other body parts on any autopsy for an elder. There would be no proof at to where or when they occurred.

Falls are, again, the norm. The aging brain loses ability to balance. Falls are often the beginning of the end and it was so for my own mom in her 90s. Pneumonia was once "the old person's friend" and took our elders to the gates of Pearl. Now it is often falls, which, unlike pneumonia, have no cure.

This doesn't mean that you cannot consult an attorney. If he wishes to accept such a case on contingency it may give you some comfort at least in what is found on investigation. But if the attorney wants money up front from you this is your fist clue that you are being taken to the cleaners. You have almost no chance of winning a suit.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

If a care taker claims he was a care taker and coerce a dementia person to sign 4 loans and quit claim title our family home
How go about this matter
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Jgdodd57
Report
MACinCT Jul 29, 2024
Jdgdodd67 You need to post your own question which is entirely different
(1)
Report
'Can you file?' Yes you can, if you can pay the fees, but it may be struck out if there is no prospect of success. ‘What are my odds of winning’. Winning WHAT?

Winning money? How much money have you lost, to claim back? Damages are about money compensation for loss.
Winning a moral victory and revenge? That’s not what a damages claim is about, so good luck.

If you don’t win money, who is going to pay the legal bills?
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
waytomisery Jul 20, 2024
“ Winning money ? How much money have you lost , to claim back ? Damages are about money compensation for loss .”

Exactly . My husband is in constant pain from being hit by a car and is losing function of his hand , didn’t get a dime . . Read my story below . It’s in two replies under Grandma1954 . The jury awarded DH nothing because he’s able to work . He hasn’t lost his salary . The jury didn’t even award my DH money to reimburse us for out of pocket medical costs , deductibles and copays from this accident because the defense attorney painted my husband out to be a greedy person . The driver was found at fault , DH got zero anyway .
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Go for it, if you want to pursue this.]
Good luck
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to cover9339
Report

One of the ways you could file a lawsuit would be to contact one of the law firms you see on TV advertising they sue Nursing Homes for wrongful deaths or injuries. If they take the case you know it would be "winnable"
Yes they take a good chunk but anyth8ing left is more than what you have now correct? And from what I understand if they don't win, you don't pay. That is why I say if they take the case you know it is winnable.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report
waytomisery Jul 19, 2024
I agree OP should talk to a lawyer with the details that we don’t have here . For example , if this fall was actually that staff dropped him from a hoyer lift , that would be a different scenario than the elderly man just falling on his own.

Not all personal injury civil cases are slam dunks though even if the lawyer thought it was winnable . Just ask my husband who was a pedestrian in a parking garage and hit by a car . He had surgery to his arm , permanent nerve damage , losing more and more function to his dominant hand every day .

The driver’s car insurance company’s lawyer argued that either the surgeon screwed up , or my husband didn’t heal correctly because he’s Type 2 diabetic . He also argued that it’s possible my DH had diabetic neuropathy prior to the accident and was trying to now blame his pain on the accident , to profit . He used my husbands diabetes and paid some 80 year old retired surgeon to testify that my DH was still in pain and was losing function , due to his diabetes.

Didn’t matter to these jurors that my husband would not have needed surgery at all if he wasn’t hit . Didn’t matter to them that there was no documented medical record of him having any problems to that limb prior to this accident. Didn’t matter that my DH has no history of neuropathy anywhere at all .
The car insurance lawyer stressed that my DH was still working and not losing wages . Yeah but he struggles, takes him longer to do his job .

You never know with jurors in civil trials is what our lawyer said , not always a slam dunk , sometimes you get surprised . I knew we lost 1/2 way through by watching the jurors faces , so did our lawyer . Jurors awarded not a penny , not even out of pockets expenses for the surgery or PT .

My brother is a retired criminal trial prosecutor . I’ll always remember what he said about the outcome of trials .
“ It’s not about the truth , it’s what the jury believes is the truth “.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
In order to prevail in such a lawsuit you will have to show tangible, documented proof of negligence on the part of the SNF. That’s a very high hurdle. If you don’t win your case, you pay attorney’s fees for both parties; your own and the nursing home. Your odds of winning such a case are extremely low. Perhaps you should consider getting some grief counseling to help you through your anger and grief. A lawsuit won’t bring you the peace and comfort you seek.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to RLWG54
Report

Waifubash, one thing to think about.... if your grandfather was living with a relative and he ended up falling and dying of his injury, would you sue your relative? Even if your grandfather was found to have had previous injuries from a fall?
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to freqflyer
Report
BurntCaregiver Jul 19, 2024
If a relative was providing care and getting paid upwards of ten, fifteen, twenty thousand dollars a month like nursing homes get, damn right I'd sue them if my grandfather got a broken neck and paralyzed while in their care.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
Consult with an attorney since none of us know all of the details and facts. Your first hurdle is finding someone to take the case. Forget about winning.

1) find a lawyer to take the case
2) find EVIDENCE of neglect and wrongdoing (how? This won’t be easy)
3) settle if you can
4) if it ever reaches the point of trial, assume 3-5 years for resolution

This is my POV.

Other people are correct in that MANY elders have fractured spines. It’s a part of living and getting old.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Southernwaver
Report

The odds of you winning anything are slim and none, I am sorry to say.

You can have a consultation with a personal injury lawfirm that spcializes in nursing home neglect and abuse. It's worth a try. They will investigate.

Going in, understand that nursing home regulations for 'industry standards' are extremely low. You will be shocked at what is within industry standards in a nursing home. Especially ones in Florida. They are literally the worst state in the country for nursing home regulations.

See the lawyers and let them review the case. If it finds that the nursing home met industry standards in the state of Florida, you will not be able to sue for wrongful death.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report
MargaretMcKen Jul 19, 2024
Burnt's answer an hour earlier is a little different - 'everyone has a right to file' though not to win. My response there briefly is "The issue is whether there are cash damages for which to claim. .... Civil courts and civil lawyers don't deal in 'revenge'. That's what 'complaints' are for".
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Where I live, a death with history of a recent fall in a care facility is a reportable death to the State Coroner. The case is assessed. Signs of abuse or neglect are looked for.

I do not know the statistcs, but falls in the elderly population with advanced dementia are common. Very common. I expect it would be a rare case where evidence is found for abuse or neglect.

Many factors contribute to falls;
. Elderly people lose muscle mass
. Balance becomes poor
. People with dementia have actual brain changes that reduces their ability to walk over time
. They fall & don't always report it

Falls prevention stategies can be used with AIM to REDUCE falls.

But expectations that ALL falls can be prevented, ongoing, is not reasonable.

Note: Falls previention stategies are used in a home setting or a care facility.

When I read posts similar to this, I can't help think the poster is at the angry stage of grief. Looking to find reason & lay blame for the loss of their loved one. Grief councelling may be more appropriate to help process emotions & move on to the acceptance.

It may read as insulting, but I will be frank: Avoid thinking your LO would not have fallen if you were there, if you were watching, if you were helping. A family member can sit & watch, camera & falls alarm mats can be used. Low beds, crash mats on the floor. All of it. A person can fall & will fall in an instant.

People trip, slip, slide off bed edge. Lean forward & fall from chairs or wheelchairs. Lose balance turning or bending, legs give way. Or they drop like a stone when blood pressure drops, have a stroke or heart attack.

But no-one is a superhero that can prevent any of that from happening.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Beatty
Report
waytomisery Jul 19, 2024
Same where I live , if they fall and die within I think 24 hours , it’s reportable , I could be wrong on the number of hours though .

A fall is very common and like you listed is caused by many reasons and not always preventable,

A drop out of a hoyer lift is a whole different scenario . Years ago I knew a family who won a settlement because their mother fell off a toilet , broke a hip and eventually died weeks later . I think she was at the SNF for rehab after a stroke . Her care plan said she was to have someone with her at all times in the bathroom . The CNA left her alone in the bathroom to go get clean clothing .

OP didn’t give details of the fall , I assumed it was a generic non preventable one.
(0)
Report
How to make a claim for wrongful death? Best done by a young widow with 3 children after the death of a husband with a very well paid job. Their financial damages are large, and clear.

Your financial damages? Forget it! Your ‘wrongful death’ claim is about punishment, which is not what a civil claim is for.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
BurntCaregiver Jul 19, 2024
Not true, Margaret. Anyone has a right to file a wrongful death suit if they have a reason to. Not just widows with kids.

Even if revenge is the driving factor in a wrongful death suit, so what. People have a right to be angry when their loved one dies because others did wrong.
They have a right to satisfaction. The court decides if their suit has merit and damages are awarded.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
A very sick elderly person with at least one terminal illness dying is not a wrongful death, sorry.

Nature has taken its natural course.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to ZippyZee
Report
BurntCaregiver Jul 19, 2024
@Zippy

You're mistaken. It very well can be if that person is supposed to be a lift/transfer assist x2 and wasn't. Just because a person is old and sick does not mean that they should die of a broken neck because the facility that was getting paid to take care of them ignored safety and let that happen.

It's not the nursing home resident or their family's fault if the nursing home is understaffed and everyone is working themselves to the bone. Too damn bad. They're still collecting the huge money every month and for that they are supposed to do their jobs.

That's when you go to a personal injury lawfirm and let them investigate. If they find nothing to sue for, then there's nothing to sue for.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
I'm so sorry for you great loss! My 96yr old Dad, who has moderate dementia, has taken several falls already - none of which resulted in major injuries, just bumps & bruises, thankfully. As much as I personally walk around like a crazy person trying to be his guard, with dementia, falls are going to happen. I'd try to make peace in knowing your Grandfather didn't have to suffer through all the later complications of dementia - it's a horrible disease. I fully believe no one leaves this planet until it is their time. I wish you & your family much peace.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Mamacrow
Report

Dementia is terminal and the death is horrific. There was no way to put my mom out of her misery, which meant that she suffered to the end, day after day, unable to walk or talk, her body contracted into a fetal position. You don’t see this in the warm fuzzy videos of loving family gathered around a smiling peaceful granny holding a bouquet of daisies.

If a fall had taken her life before mom turned into a living corpse, I would have been more than grateful.

I send you sincere condolences on the loss of your grandfather.
Helpful Answer (11)
Reply to Fawnby
Report

Falls are a common cause of death for the elderly . I’m sure it happens many times a day in Florida .

There is no way to prevent every fall , especially for people with severe dementia.

In wrongful death lawsuits , they take into account the age , health , life expectancy , earning potential , whether or not the deceased was a breadwinner , had minors, dependents to support.

I doubt a lawyer will take your case . The lawyer has to make money. The lawyer gets paid from the amount awarded . They typically charge a fee for time , and expenses, then after that they take 1/3 of what is left . That would leave you less than 2/3 . Lawyers don’t take cases that will be awarded little to no money which would be the case for your grandfather . If any money was awarded it would be so little that it would all go to pay the lawyer for the hourly fees and expenses including court fees , leaving you nothing.

Your grandfather was terminal with severe dementia , next to no life expectancy left , he was not earning money , he wasn’t supporting anyone as the breadwinner . He was at the end of his life , and died a common way that elderly die .

Your grandfather’s death was not the same as a young healthy man , with many years of life expectancy , dying wrongfully , who was and would be earning money for many more years , and leaving behind a young family and children to support . That is how the value of these lawsuits are determined .

Condolences for your loss .
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to waytomisery
Report

I'm sorry that your grandfather and family went through this. We aren't lawyers, which is who you need to consult. Mostly you give us 0 useable information, like:

- when did this happen?
- who put him in the NH?
- what were the circumstances that preceded him being put in there?
- who was your Grandfather's PoA or legal guardian?
- was kind of facility was he in? (AL, MC, LTC?)

An attorney will need to know this and more. One consult will probably be enough to determine if you have a winnable case or not.

Just so you know, elders falling in facilities, and even in their own homes, and getting severely injured and dying is unfortunately very common problem. My 100-yr old Aunt with severe dementia fell in her own home, on carpeting, and broke her hip. She was in rehab when she passed and cause of death was not obvious but most likely a clot that frequently is a result of a large bone break, or the fact that she was in a different environment and wasn't eating or drinking normally, despite the family being there several hours every day. We view her quick passing as more of a blessing, even though we miss her so much.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to Geaton777
Report

Anyone can file a lawsuit for any reason, do you all have 10s of thousands of dollars to pursue a lawsuit? Because you will need it and you should set aside an equal amount to pay for their legal fees, because you will be paying both bills if you lose.

Your grandpa was in a nursing home, he was dying, why can you all not see this? Old people fall, it is part of life. How do you know all the injuries were not part of the same fall? You can do whatever you choose, personally, I don't think you have a snowballs chance to win.
Helpful Answer (8)
Reply to Isthisrealyreal
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter