Follow
Share

My mother who is 81 is housebound due to Arthritis. She doesn’t make an effort to do anything, doesn’t open windows, sits in front of that tv all day and night. We have had brilliant weather and she won’t even sit outside for fresh air and all she does is complain about the Carers. I was away with work for a week and had a great time when I came back I went round to see her and she depresses the life out of me and I leave feeling really down. She lives in a bungalow so could quite easy sit outside but says she doesn’t want to surely this isn’t normal to live in a house and never see daylight this has gone on for 2 years now any advice is welcome thanks

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
If it’s HER normal life, it may be really tough to break the pattern.

How is her general health? Is she seen by a physician or other medical specialist on a regular basis?

Does she have regular blood work done?

Do you associate her behavior with depression or anxiety?

What was she like BEFORE 2 years ago? Did she enjoy a more active life style?

In her description of her, you mention MANY specific complaints that can and do diminish enjoyment of active life. Hearing loss, depression/anxiety both shrink interest and enthusiasm for activity, even of the type that others of the same age as she is find pleasant.

Does she have any social contacts from her younger days who are still living? Loss of associates is painful, and some elderly are more comfortable letting themselves forget about the past rather than wistfully revisiting it.

Consider- you may be terribly depressed by her behavior at present, but you have your own life and your own feelings. SHE doesn’t depress you. YOU, in a loving attempt to empathize with her and attempt to solve her problems, project YOUR SADNESS for her and for where she is right now.

You have people caring for her when you’re not in her area. Rely on them to do what needs to be done, but keep in touch with their reports about her complaints. If they can tell you something objective and specific about something you can change regarding her present situation, CHANGE IT. If there is nothing to “FIX”, take comfort that you’ve tried, and let her enjoy her griping and TV.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

As BarbBrooklyn noted, she should be assessed for depression (which is very common in the elderly) but also for dementia. I'm not sure if she's in the States but in my home state (MN) in my metro area health network we have pain clinics where they work to address the pain from a number of health problems, including arthritis. My 92-yr old mom has no more cartilage in either knee and it is painful to walk, yet mobility in old age is very important. She is on Tylenol but also has the resources for gel injections that act as cartilage. It has been successful in greatly minimizing the pain so she can resume gardening and driving. When that no longer works, we will consider nerve ablation, a minimally invasive and low-risk procedure where they cauterize the nerves that signal the arthritis pain. It doesn't cure the arthritis, just takes away the pain and the need for taking large doses of pain meds (and their side effects). So, if she is near or has access to any pain clinics, please pursue this with her -- she does not need to be completely hindered by her arthritis.

Then there is the issue of loneliness. Are there any senior centers that provide transport for elders in her area? You may need to go with her the first few times (if she's physically able and mentally willing). Wishing you success in helping her better her situation!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Taylorb1 Jun 2021
Thank you but she can’t leave the house now due to not being able to walk down the 5 stairs that she has in her bungalow we are in Scotland I have contacted her doctor but she refused help I work full time so it’s hard trying to arrange anything for her and wouldn’t be able to get her out of the house I appreciate what you have said so thanks again
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
When my dad was struggling with the duel issues common to aging, emotional losses and physical ailments, his doctor spoke to him brilliantly one day, never using the word “depression” but describing how dad might be feeling. Dad agreed that he was feeling down and the doctor started him on Zoloft. It was a big help. He became less depressed and more content, and felt like resuming activities as he could.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

SHe is of clear mind? Then leave her alone to wallow in her own self pity or pleasure. In time she may get bored and there will be no discussion on your part about it giving her the extra attention. She is doing what she wants to do and just because YOU think the weather is brilliant and she should be enjoying it, maybe SHE doesn't or doesn't want to. Feeling depressed is on you. Establish some boundaries or time limits on your visit. ANd plan on a reward for yourself afterwards.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Please have her doctor evaluate her for depression, which many seniors have. Also talk with her doctor about her arthritis management. She needs to move daily since being still actually worsens it (I have some arthritis too). She should probably have oral medications (Aleve is a good one) and maybe topical medications (Voltaren cream or gel works well).
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Taylorb1 Jul 2021
Thank you very much yes she complains about being in constant pain every day but she sits in front of that tv all day and night then complains that her legs don’t work will see her doctor about that medication thanks again
(0)
Report
Leave her to it - she has mental capacity to make decisions so leave her to make her own decisions until or unless she loses that capacity.
We may not like the decisions our elderly parents make but they are entitled to make them and we need to butt out until they ask for assistance or someone HAS to get involved. If you do not have POA then it would be a good idea to work with her to get this set up before any loss in mental capacity means it cannot be done. You don't get authority unless she gives it just because it exists but it is useful to have in place for any future need.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I must agree with TaylorUK.
If your mother is still of sound mind then leave her to it to live as she wants.
You say she complains incessantly to you about her Carers. I would suggest you talk to them privately and ask them what she's like when they're with her. It could very well be that she gets on perfectly well with them, but just wants to complain to you about something. Talk to them.
Some years back I worked for an old Irish guy here. He was sick and had stopped going out and didn't leave the house except to go to the doctor. His wife was completely invalid with dementia and had to be housebound. She couldn't be taken out anymore. They had other caregivers (carers) who were always complaining because because he wouldn't eat for them, or willing to get up, or do anything else.
One day when I came to their house for work, I poured us each a pint of Guinness (I had checked with his doctor to make sure he could have it) and put it them on the outside table in the yard. He came out and we sat out there having our pints for almost an hour. We didn't talk much. I didn't do the ridiculously forced cheeriness that so many people who work with the elderly feel they have to do. The other caregivers did this. Our pints became a regular thing. When I took over the morning hours, he started eating again because he wanted a proper Irish breakfast and the other caregivers didn't know what this was. They also didn't know how to make a proper cup of tea for him. After several months, I was able to get him to go out a little. For a drive or out for lunch.
Talk to your mother's Carers. It could be they're just not taking the right approach with her. Sometimes small things like having a drink with the person or eating with them is enough to start getting them to do more like go outside or open the shades.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Beatty Jul 2021
A wonderful story ❤️

Culture is so important.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Profile says she has dementia which can explain a lot of her behavior. As others note, could be depressed as well.

Do her caregivers try to get her to go outside? Fresh air and sunshine (vitamin D!) could be good for her mood. They can have meals outdoors with her. They could/should be doing things with her to improve her life at least a little bit. Even if she says she doesn't want to, depending on her level of dementia, she may not really know much about what she would really like at this point.

Wait, can she get out of her house? With her arthritis? If not, if she has any money, have a ramp built. Put her in a wheelchair and get her out of the house that way. How about some PT to help with her pain? So many options/ideas shared here from everyone but if she will NOT do it, then that's that. You can try though!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Taylorb1 Jul 2021
Thank you much appreciated I will take this on board x
(0)
Report
No not normal behavior it's the behavior of someone who's given up. Is she in pain? Arthritis pain makes opening a window or doing most things not worth the effort. When you visit, is it all about just giving her a chance to complain, or talking about her? That is depressing for all involved. On a gorgeous day I would take her outside (don't take no for an answer), sit with her, maybe eat a favorite treat, chat and be cheerful. Direct the conversation so that it's not about her (I think complaining about things is the only power left to people in her situation so that's why they do it). This is what I do with my mother, I chatter away (mostly about current events, gossip, etc), make jokes and can almost always get her out of her funk.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Taylorb1,

Maybe in addition to your mom's caregivers who only come in for 15 minutes just for her basic needs, you could get her a companion.
Someone who's only job is hanging out with a person.
Companions are strictly for socialization. They don't do housekeeping or hands-on care.
They spend time with the client, do recreational activities, and take the client out.
Your mother might like to have someone coming around who isn't about her health conditions and care needs.
Years ago when I was young I was a companion to an elderly man who had been a university professor and a music prodigy.
He didn't live alone. His cousin and her husband moved into his gorgeous home and pretty much just took it over and didn't give him the time of day. Fortunately they didn't have full control of his money and assets though.
At the time I was from an agency and his insurance was paying for me. Otherwise his family wouldn't have been on board with such a service. He absolutely refused to go to adult daycare like his cousin insisted he do and rightly so. He didn't have dementia. He was just elderly and not in the best of health. My friend worked at the day care facility he went to. The place was nice, clean, and the staff was friendly. There was no way that a man like him was going to play bingo, do a puzzle, or have a sing-a-long with the people in the day care.
We started going out to all kinds of places. Excellent restaurants, museum exhibits, libraries, etc... The university he taught at was right in town and he liked to go and listen to the program rehearsals going on for the concert seasons. Everyone knew him and he loved doing this. He also started to enjoy spending his own money again which grieved his family greatly. He didn't drive anymore and I had no problem taking him to the bank any time he wanted. His 'caregiver' family really blew a gasket when we went to Brooks Brothers so he could buy himself a new suit. Anyway, a good companion can make a great difference in someone's life.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter