Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
I lost my mother to cancer after a four-year battle. I watched her go from a vibrant, distinguished lady to someone who was bedridden and weighed 70 pounds at the end. During her illness she lost the ability to eat due to an unrelated esophagus issue. I, her son, had to help her dress and other things a mother should not have to endure.

My father has been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s for over 10 years, during which my mother passed away from cancer. I was the caregiver for both. My father has required 24-7 care for about the last 3 years and, aside, from a little help, I have provided that care. He is a shell of his former self. Indeed, rarely do I see anything left of who was once my father. I do not know if he will be here 10 more days or 10 more years.

If I had my choice as the survivor or the person passing, make it quick. I would prefer to deal with the shocking, painful, suddenness rather than the long painful death anytime. Nevertheless, we do not get to choose.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report

I have been pondering the same thing.

My father died suddenly. It was a massive stroke that led to an automobile accident (fortunately no one else was involved). With his death, I saw my mother go through quite a bit of anger. She even said, numerous times, “if he came to the door right now. I don’t know if I’d let him in.”

When dad died, he left a financial mess that took several years to reconcile. Mom and I learned from that experience and made sure that we left everything in good shape for her death and I am doing the same thing for my children.

My mom’s death was expected. After pneumonia and hospice and vascular dementia, she went peacefully in her sleep.

My job as executor has been easier with mom. But that is the only part that is easier. To paraphrase other responses. In my experience, with sudden death there can be anger and shock and grief. With expected death, there is some relief and grief.

I see grief as a path we must walk. The path is different for every survivor. Some areas are smooth. Some areas are uphill. Some areas are rocky and almost impassable. With time the walk becomes more familiar and less painful. But it is a path we are always on.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

An anticipated death is probably "different" more than easier. Even after a long period of illness and care taking and multiple medical crises, the death brings shock and disbelief. I have not had someone close die suddenly; I would think the shock of a sudden death would be greater but would not have been preceded by months or years of anxiety, trauma, and emotional upheaval.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

No it's not easier, but like already said, it's just different. I've experienced both the quick deaths and lingering and anticipating deaths.
My late husband who I was told wasn't going to make it through the night in Nov. 2018 as he had aspiration pneumonia, ended up living but developed sepsis and septic shock and was completely bedridden. On top of all that he also had vascular dementia, so when he did die in Sept. 2020, while I was sad to lose the man I loved, there was also relief that he no longer had to suffer.
So I guess with a sudden death there is shock and grief and with a death that is expected there is relief and grief.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Grandma1954
July 26, 2023 7:55 am

Tryingmybest19,
I thought about this a lot.
After my Husband died I attended the Bereavement Support Group that Hospice had.
There was a woman there that told her story, her husband had a back ache, it did not resolve with typical home remedies so he went to the doctor. Doctor gave him muscle relaxer medication and that did not work so he sent him for some tests, (not sure if it was an X-ray or MRI) but the result came back stage 4 cancer that had spread from the spine throughout his body. His pain was unmanageable, he was admitted to Hospice. Hospice had him transferred to the In Patient Unit to manage the pain. His wife went home once he was settled in and several hours later she got a call that he had died. This was all in a 3 week time span.
I had 12 years after the diagnosis of Alzheimer's with my Husband.
I thought I was prepared. I knew what was going to happen. I read the books. I saw him decline. I watched him go from a smiling, joking man to a shell.
the morning he died I felt as if someone had ripped the heart from my chest and stomped on it.

Fast....
12 years.....
It hurts.
It is raw...
Death is never easy on the ones left behind.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report

My only experience so far was with my nearly 101-yr old Aunt who had advanced dementia at the end. Her actual self was long gone, over the 10+ years of her dementia journey. She was leaving in increments, and my grief was happening in increments, also. So, when she passed it was a relief. May you receive peace in your heart!
Helpful Answer (18)
Report

I think there is no “easier”, whether anticipated or not, having experienced both.

My father dropped dead in his asparagus garden at age 72, 2 weeks after his first grandchild was born, the happiest event in his life.

My mother lingered, happy and safe and comfortable, in residential care until a week before her 95th birthday, and passed after a week in hospice care, in her sleep.

My recent LO was in hospice for a year and a half, for the last year of that time covered with pressure ulcers, and died 6 months after her 94th birthday.

Some easier, some harder, no pattern except trying to learn, on my part, that each loss has its own pattern.

Most were loved, are missed, and now, are fondly remembered.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

I haven't lost either of my parents yet but I think it is easier when it is not a shock.

I remember your previous posting about your mom being so ill. I hope you are doing okay. (((((hugs))))).
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

No, it's just different.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I think one’s reaction depends a lot on the age of the dead person also.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

When a person dies suddenly it is a shock. When they die after a slow painful illness it is a relief.

Even with the relief comes sorrow and even though we know death is imminent, somehow it is still a surprise that our loved one is truly gone.

For me, the younger someone is the greater the loss feels as they have not lived what we think of as a full life. The elderly, we console ourselves have lived a long full life.

There are, of course, always exceptions and no age or relief of illness can ever console us when our grief is fresh. Time doesn’t heal all but it does allow us to absorb the shock and accept that we all do die.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report

No. There is nothing worse than watching someone slowly die. My father died after a very brief (2 weeks) illness, and I have found it way easier than watching my mother die slowly. Her mind is gone, her body is failing, she can only lie in bed and talk nonsense. Every positive memory I have of her is being slowly tarnished as I have watched her become a husk of a person over the past 3 and a half years.

Not only is it painful watching someone waste away so slowly, I am constantly on alert to "the phone call". She has been in hospice 3 times but always improves enough to have hospice removed. Anticipating a phone call for over 3 years is tortuous. Seeing someone waste away is even more so. So no, it is not easier in my opinion, it is the most painful, dreadful experience someone can endure.
Helpful Answer (14)
Report
Tryingmybest19 Jul 2023
You and I seem to be in the same position...it's heartwrenching. I love my mom so very much but this last month of sickness, and last 2 years of slow decline are just torture. I hope we (and our moms) find peace.
(16)
Report
See 1 more reply
I think in some ways it is easier. I knew it was coming with both parents and came to understand how very tired they were of life with so many health issues. It was very hard to lose them but also hard to wish either of them back knowing they were ready to go. I wish you peace
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter