Follow
Share

Edited because I sometimes go on and on...


I'm concerned about my mom having psych tests as part of a memory improvement treatment program. The tests will be administered by a clinical psychologist. What if they diagnose her with early dementia or something? She may be slowing down, but I can’t imagine she has anything serious yet. Would a diagnosis mean she had to leave her current residence, even if she seems fine? I guess I’m paranoid, but I’ve always played my own life pretty close to the vest and I’m uneasy about her getting into something that will mess up her life.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
I don't think it can hurt, but I'm not sure it can help either. According to what I've read, a paper published in the Journal of Neuroscience found no evidence that playing brain games, specifically Lumosity, translated into improvements in cognitive functioning or decision making. Your mom may be better off doing crossword puzzles or other word games in general to keep her mind active.

What concerns me about test scores is that she may feel badly if her score isn't as high as others.....leading her to feel badly about herself possibly, you know? Other than that, I don't think these games are designed to diagnose dementia or to threaten her living independently. It's probably more of a money making venture combined with a fun/social activity designed to improve oneself.

Whatever you decide to do, good luck!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
TXGirl82 Sep 2019
Thank you for the reply. I agree that the games probably don't make a huge difference. I remember when the Lumosity had to stop claiming in the commercials that their games improved memory. Perhaps the FTC made them stop? Or the FDA?

My concern is not really the games, but the psych eval. (I went on too long in my "question".) I don't want her to feel badly -- agree with you especially there -- but I also don't want an official diagnosis to be used against her in some way.

It may not be the big deal I'm afraid it is.

Thank you again!
(1)
Report
My suggestion would be to ask the psychologist which tests (what are the names of the tests) she/he wants to administer. Psych tests are standardised tools readily available and often you can find them on the internet. If not available on the internet you could ask to view the tests. That way you can check the purpose and content to see whether you are comfortable it being administered to your mom. Alternatively you could ask the psychologist to explain the content and purpose of the testing. I'm assuming they're wanting to know her capacity to devise a program to match her needs.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
TXGirl82 Sep 2019
Thank you for the reply.

I will talk to the psychologist. That's a good idea. I think you area correct that they want to learn where she is so they can help, but I also think they may be conducting a study.
(0)
Report
I'm assuming that your mom will be administered a standardized IQ test (not readily available on the internet and you can't preview the actual test due to test security measures) as well as some standardized tests of memeory, reasoning and neurological functioning.

My mom had this sort of evaluation; in the "debriefing" several weeks later, the neurologist who was part of the team gently told my mother that she should no longer be living alone ( she had already moved to an Independent Living facility, so it confirmed that that had been a good idea) and made several other recomme rations for lifestyle changes. She was diagnosed with Mild Cognitive Impairment; no scores were ever divulged, to her or to us.

We found it very useful and actionable information. Is your mother currently living alone?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
TXGirl82 Sep 2019
She is living in an independent living community. I don't see any alarming symptoms or anything.

If a person is diagnosed as having mild impairment, does that mean they can't drive anymore?

Thank you for taking the time to reply.
(1)
Report
TXgirl, does she live in a place that has stipulations in her lease that concerns you?

I can't imagine that she would have to move based on tests. I think that behavior and needs would drive that action.

She can not be deemed incompetent without a hearing and a judge would be the only one that could label her as incompetent. Of course they rely on Doctors and test results, behavior and other things to make this determination. It is a BIG deal, people lose their rights with that determination and it is not easy to get.

I can understand your hesitation with all the potential problems involved with mental health diagnosis. We live in a time that costs you some rights and you never know where it will go.

I hope she is okay and you find help for her without having to subject her to more unpleasantness.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
TXGirl82 Sep 2019
Good point. I will take a look at her lease. You are probably right that behavior would drive a decision that she couldn't stay. Her behavior is normal.

Thank you for your understanding and for your reply.
(0)
Report
You or she can decline to be tested right now. Unless you have serious concerns, she can just wait. They are mandated reporters for the DMV but I’m not sure how it could be used against her otherwise. We went in to get a baseline and I was shocked that my husband was diagnosed with mild dementia.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
TXGirl82 Sep 2019
Thank you for replying. I don't have concerns... the testing is part of the program which includes memory games and discussions on improving memory.

Maybe we should ask whether she can skip the psych test. It's her decision, but she has been talking to me about whether she should even participate, and I got to thinking...

Thank you again.
(0)
Report
I do not believe that Mild Cognitive Impairment means that you cant drive anymore. My mother had given up driving at the point where she was tested, so it was a moot point.

Can you discuss with the psychologist, prior to the testing session, if s/he would be mandated to report your mother to DMV if there were a certain level of impairment demonstrated on the testing?

I believe this varies from state to state.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

My mom's concern when we went for testing was " well, if they tell me I'm crazy, I'm going to argue with them".

Can your mother elucidate what her hesitancy is?

For us, as a family, it was a valuable experience. It got my brother to quit saying that mom's anxiety was just her having a pity party. It validated the fact that there was cognitive loss.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

A clinical psychologist is not a physician but rather a PhD. They are part of the clinical treatment team but do not practice medicine and do not diagnose.

Independent living places are unlikely to remove well-behaving residents. My FIL also lives in an independent living community and has mild dementia. He keeps to himself most of the day but participates in exercise classes and meals. He has no behavioral issues that make him a risk to have live there.

Check the lease - the language is probably pretty vague - and until something actually happens I would not worry about it. Our plan for my FIL is for him to continue living there unless he needs to move to the memory care building.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

If you don't evaluate your memory at the beginning, how will you know if the program is working?

In any case, an assessment is not a diagnosis. The clinical psychologist will take various measurements of various types of cognitive function; but as to the cause of any present conditions - the cause of any apparent problem could be something as simple as your mother's not paying attention or needing the loo. This is NOT going to lead to her losing her driving licence or being forced into memory care; but - doesn't sound like it, but - it could flag up things to keep an eye on. How would that hurt?

By all means check the program's data protection credentials if you're still worried. I personally wouldn't be any more worried about this than I would be about doing a quiz in Good Housekeeping to see if my marriage will last.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Clinical Psychologists most certainly DO make diagnoses within their scope of practice.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
NYDaughterInLaw Sep 2019
Nurses also diagnose within their scope of practice but it's not the kind of diagnosis that I thought we were talking about here. I am under the impression that only physicians can make a medical diagnosis that has legal consequences e.g. reporting to DMV, guardianship, etc. If I am incorrect, please let me know.
(1)
Report
Are you thinking that if she IS diagnosed with dementia that you and/or she will be able to keep her condition a secret?
A large portion of my professional life was spent in a therapeutic field, and believe me, KNOWLEDGE IS POWER.
If she is tested, she will have confidentiality rights, and will be able to exercise her own judgment as to what she chooses to share with whom.

Funny story on myself, I am totally incapable of repeating strings of numbers or random letters backwards, from memory. I would have been failing that portion of cognitive testing years ago.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter